News about giving, foundations and nonprofits

AboutStandardsAdvertise

Policy & LawExplainer

The Supreme Court's 2026 First Choice ruling: a nonprofit's federal challenge to a donor subpoena can proceed

In April 2026 the Supreme Court let a New Jersey nonprofit challenge a state demand for its donors' names in federal court. What it decided and left open.

By Policy Desk · Published 

In brief

  • On April 29, 2026, a unanimous Supreme Court held that a nonprofit served with a state subpoena for its donors' identities had a present First Amendment injury and could sue in federal court.
  • New Jersey's attorney general had demanded the names, addresses and employers of donors to First Choice Women's Resource Centers in a subpoena citing the state's Consumer Fraud Act.
  • The lower courts had dismissed the case because no New Jersey court had yet ordered the group to hand over any documents.
  • The Court decided only that the lawsuit may go ahead. Whether the demand itself violates the First Amendment is left to the lower courts.
  • The ruling is final at the Supreme Court: its docket records the judgment as issued on June 1, 2026, sending the case back to the Third Circuit.

On April 29, 2026, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled unanimously that First Choice Women's Resource Centers, a religious nonprofit in New Jersey, may challenge a state subpoena for the identities of its donors in federal court, without first waiting for a state judge to order it to comply. Writing for the Court in First Choice Women's Resource Centers, Inc. v. Davenport, No. 24-781, Justice Gorsuch held that the group "has established a present injury to its First Amendment associational rights" and so had standing to sue.

The decision settles a question of timing that matters to any charity asked by a state official for its donor records: when it can go to a federal court to object. It does not decide whether New Jersey's demand was lawful.

The subpoena

Since 1985 First Choice has given pregnant women in New Jersey counseling and resources and, because it believes life begins at conception, does not provide abortions or refer clients for them, according to the opinion. In 2022 the state's then attorney general, Matthew Platkin, set up a Reproductive Rights Strike Force, whose consumer alert accused groups like First Choice of giving false or misleading information about abortion. In 2023 his office served First Choice with a subpoena issued under several state laws, among them the Consumer Fraud Act.

The subpoena listed 28 categories of documents. The one at the center of the case sought the names, phone numbers, addresses and places of employment of everyone who had given to First Choice since January 1, 2021, by any means other than one specific donation webpage. It warned twice that failure to comply could bring contempt of court. Platkin later said his office hoped to "contact a representative sample" of donors to learn whether they had "been misled" about the group's "mission and operations"; in his view, its fundraising materials could lead donors to think it provides abortions, the opinion says.

Why the lower courts turned the group away

Two days before its deadline to produce documents, First Choice sued in federal district court under 42 U.S.C. 1983, the federal civil rights statute, and the attorney general then went to state court to enforce the subpoena. The federal district court denied First Choice a preliminary injunction and dismissed its complaint. Because no state court had ordered First Choice to produce anything, it reasoned, the group had not yet suffered an injury and lacked standing under Article III of the Constitution. A divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed in a decision dated December 12, 2024. Judge Bibas dissented.

What the Court decided

The Supreme Court reversed. Since NAACP v. Alabama in 1958, the opinion says, the Court has subjected official demands for private donor or member information to heightened First Amendment scrutiny, most recently in Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta in 2021. It said its cases "have long recognized that demands for a charity's private member or donor information" discourage people from associating with a group, and that this happens "not just when a demand is enforced, but when it is made and for as long as it remains outstanding."

New Jersey had argued that First Choice suffered no injury yet. Its brief stressed that the subpoena "is not self-executing": under state law, penalties follow only if a state court orders production and the group is then held in contempt for not complying, and the state trial court had repeatedly declined to order production and told the two sides to negotiate. The state also pointed out that donors could still give anonymously through one website and that a protective order, which it had been negotiating with the group, would keep donors' names from being disclosed.

The Court rejected each point. Donors would reasonably fear disclosure whether or not the subpoena could be enforced at once, it said. Steering donors to a single website still burdened the group's freedom to associate with them, and no protective order existed. A letter in which the attorney general offered to narrow the demand to donors who gave through two websites, sent the day before the Third Circuit heard argument, did not end the case, because it reserved the right to seek other donors' identities through a separate subpoena.

What it left open

The Court said the case presented "a narrow question." It ruled only that First Choice's federal lawsuit may proceed, not on whether the subpoena violates the First Amendment. The federal government argued as a friend of the court for reversal, and a group of states led by Massachusetts and Washington filed a brief asking the Court to rule for New Jersey. Jennifer Davenport, who succeeded Platkin as attorney general after the case was argued, is named as the respondent.

First Choice Women's Resource Centers v. Davenport: key dates in the court records
DateStep
2023New Jersey's attorney general serves the subpoena
December 12, 2024Third Circuit decision (No. 24-3124) upholds the dismissal
January 24, 2025Supreme Court dockets First Choice's petition (No. 24-781)
December 2, 2025Argument
April 29, 2026Decision: judgment reversed and case remanded, unanimously
June 1, 2026Supreme Court judgment issued; the case returns to the Third Circuit

What applies now

The ruling is final at the Supreme Court. Its docket, checked on November 12, 2026, records the judgment, dated April 29, as issued on June 1, 2026, and no petition for rehearing or later entry. The judgment reversed the Third Circuit, sent the case back to it "for further proceedings consistent with the opinion of this Court" and ordered New Jersey's attorney general to pay First Choice $12,488 in costs. Whether New Jersey's demand for donor information is lawful is for the lower courts to decide.

For other charities, the decision fixes when a federal challenge can begin. By the Court's reasoning, a nonprofit served with an official demand for its private donor information has an injury from the moment the demand is made, so it does not have to wait for a state court to order compliance before suing. The decision says nothing on how such challenges should be decided on the merits.

Sources

  1. First Choice Women's Resource Centers, Inc. v. Davenport, No. 24-781, 608 U.S. 174 (preliminary print) Supreme Court of the United States, April 29, 2026
  2. Docket for No. 24-781 Supreme Court of the United States, June 1, 2026
  3. Judgment, No. 24-781 (reversed and remanded to the Third Circuit; costs) Supreme Court of the United States, June 1, 2026
  4. Brief for Respondent, No. 24-781 Office of the Attorney General of New Jersey (filed with the Supreme Court), October 14, 2025

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 4 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 12, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.