News about giving, foundations and nonprofits

AboutStandardsAdvertise

Policy & Law

Subsidy watchdog finds Defra's case for a £401 million Canal & River Trust grant largely well evidenced

The Subsidy Advice Unit said on November 16 that Defra should explain some claimed benefits better as it finalizes its case for a 10-year canal charity grant.

By Policy Desk ·

In brief

  • The Subsidy Advice Unit published its report on Defra's planned £401.2 million grant to the Canal & River Trust on November 16, 2026.
  • Payments would run from April 2027 to March 2037, starting at £49.99 million and falling 5% a year to £31.51 million.
  • The unit found Defra's assessment detailed, but said Defra should better explain flood, cooling and natural capital benefits if it relies on them as market failures.
  • Without the grant, 50% to 94% of the trust's navigations and towpaths would close within three to ten years, Defra's assessment says.
  • The Defra grant made up 23% of the charity's £232.6 million income in 2024-25, the report says.

The UK's Subsidy Advice Unit on November 16, 2026, published its report on a plan by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) to give the Canal & River Trust £401.2 million over 10 years. The unit, which is part of the Competition and Markets Authority, found that Defra had considered in detail whether the grant meets the subsidy control rules, but said the department should explain some of the benefits it claims more fully as it finalizes its assessment.

The trust is a charity that has managed about 2,000 miles of inland waterways in England and Wales since 2012, when it succeeded British Waterways. The unit's report is non-binding advice to Defra: it does not consider whether the grant should be given, or directly assess whether it complies with the subsidy control requirements.

A grant that shrinks every year

Payments would start at £49.99 million in 2027-28 and fall by 5% in each following year, to £31.51 million in nominal terms in 2036-37, under an agreement running from April 2027 to March 2037. Because the grant is worth more than £25 million, Defra treats it as a Subsidy of Particular Interest, and it asked the unit for a report under section 52 of the Subsidy Control Act 2022 on September 30. The unit accepted the request on October 6, its case page shows.

Defra's proposed grant to the Canal & River Trust, £ million in nominal terms (first and last years and the total from the report; the years between are our arithmetic from the 5% taper)
Financial yearGrant
2027-2849.99
2028-2947.49
2029-3045.12
2030-3142.86
2031-3240.72
2032-3338.68
2033-3436.75
2034-3534.91
2035-3633.16
2036-3731.51
Total401.2

The Defra grant made up 23% of the trust's total income of £232.6 million in 2024-25, the report says. The rest came from a mix of sources, among them property and investment returns, fees paid by boaters and for moorings, payments from utilities whose networks use canal infrastructure, and donations. Defra's annual payments have stayed the same since 2021, so they have fallen in real terms, and the new grant would mean a further cut on that level, according to Defra's assessment as the unit summarizes it.

What Defra says would happen without it

Without the grant, Defra's assessment says, the trust would immediately have to cut its spending on running, maintaining and repairing the waterways by around a third, and between 50% and 94% of its navigations and towpaths would close over three to 10 years. In the trust's own projection with no grant at all, 93.5% of the canal network would shut within three years, along with 65% of towpaths and every one of its museums and attractions. Two consultants who reviewed the trust's projections in 2022 agreed that ending the grant would force material closures, but expected them to come more gradually, the report says.

With the 5% taper, Defra projects that 2% of the trust's towpaths and 4% of its navigations would be closed by 2037, which the department regards as acceptable. It forecasts a funding gap of £479.7 million over the decade and has set the grant £78.5 million below that figure, because it expects the trust to raise up to £89 million in extra revenue.

The unit's assessment

The unit said Defra's assessment clearly showed that the grant would change the trust's behavior and pay for work that would not otherwise happen; that it was proportionate and designed to reduce the charity's reliance on public money over time; and that it had thoroughly examined the effects on competition, including leisure and business boating, moorings, water supply and the hosting of utility networks. Under the assessment, the money is ring-fenced for maintaining the network and may not go directly into the trust's commercial business, such as selling boat licenses or renting out moorings, and underperformance against key performance indicators would trigger clawback.

Its main reservation concerned market failure, the economic case for a subsidy. The unit accepted Defra's argument that free public access to towpaths is a public good. But it said that if Defra also wants to rely on flood risk management, urban cooling and natural capital as market failures, it should show why each of them counts as a positive externality or a public good in economic terms.

Defra's social cost-benefit analysis puts the grant's benefit-cost ratio at 9.4 to 1, and research commissioned by the trust valued the social benefits of its canals, towpaths, river navigations, docks and reservoirs at £4.6 billion a year between 2018 and 2022, according to the report.

What comes next

The report sets out its points for Defra to consider in finalizing its assessment. Third parties had until October 19 to send submissions, which the unit passes to Defra together with its report. Neither the report nor the case page gives a date for Defra's final decision on the grant.

Sources

  1. Subsidy Advice Unit report on the proposed subsidy to Canal & River Trust, referred by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Subsidy Advice Unit, Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK), November 16, 2026
  2. Referral of the proposed subsidy to the Canal & River Trust by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (case page) Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK), November 16, 2026
  3. Report on the proposed subsidy to the Canal & River Trust by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (publication page) Subsidy Advice Unit (GOV.UK), November 16, 2026

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 3 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 18, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.