News about giving, foundations and nonprofits

AboutStandardsAdvertise

Policy & LawExplainer

What the government's extremism consultation would change for charity trustees in England and Wales

Hate crime convictions would bar trustees automatically, and the regulator could disqualify those promoting violence or hatred. Views close December 23.

By Policy Desk ·

In brief

  • A consultation by the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, open until 5 p.m. U.K. time on December 23, 2026, covers charities in England and Wales only.
  • Unspent convictions for stirring up hatred, aggravated hate offenses, misleading the Charity Commission or serious national security crimes would bar people from serving as trustees or senior managers.
  • The Commission could also disqualify people deprived of British citizenship or excluded from the U.K., and charity office holders, past or present, who promoted violence or racial or religious hatred.
  • The Commission made 25 disqualification orders in the year to March 2026 and 37 the year before; the Tribunal has upheld all but 2 of the 16 orders appealed to a hearing.
  • In April, the Charity Finance Group and 17 other organizations asked to be consulted first, and CFG's co-CEO warned against curbs on legitimate campaigning.

The government wants to widen the grounds on which people can be barred from running a charity in England and Wales, and it is taking views from charities, trustees and the public until 5 p.m. U.K. time on December 23, 2026. The consultation, published on October 14 by the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS), sets out draft regulations that would add hate crime and national security offenses to the list that automatically disqualifies trustees, and give the Charity Commission for England and Wales two new grounds for disqualifying people at its discretion.

The changes would amend the Charities Act 2011 by secondary legislation, which the act requires the government to consult on. The draft regulations would need approval by a resolution of each House of Parliament, and the draft leaves their start date blank. Nothing has changed yet: the current disqualification rules apply until regulations are approved and in force. Charity law is devolved, so the plans do not reach Scotland or Northern Ireland.

How disqualification works now

Under section 178 of the 2011 act, a person is automatically disqualified from serving as a trustee or holding a senior management post if they fall within one of its listed cases, which include unspent convictions for offenses involving dishonesty or deception and specified offenses such as money laundering, perjury and terrorism. The Commission makes no decision in these cases, and the consultation says the primary responsibility for checking trustees and senior managers lies with each charity's trustees. Acting while disqualified is an offense carrying up to two years in prison, a fine or both.

The bar covers only those leadership roles, not other paid or voluntary work for a charity. A disqualified person can usually ask the Commission for a waiver, and the consultation says the regulator starts from the view that waivers should be refused.

Section 181A lets the Commission disqualify someone by order for up to 15 years, but only if three tests are met: one of six listed conditions applies, the person is unfit to be a trustee, and the order is desirable in the public interest to protect trust and confidence in charities. The person gets at least a month's notice and a chance to respond, the public is usually told, and the order does not take effect until any appeal to the Tribunal is over. Our guide to how the Commission investigates charities covers its other powers.

What would be added

For automatic disqualification, the draft regulations list offenses under the Public Order Act 1986 for stirring up racial hatred, religious hatred or hatred on grounds of sexual orientation, and for possessing inflammatory material; the aggravated assault, criminal damage, public order and harassment offenses in sections 29 to 32 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998, which now cover racial or religious hostility; the offense of giving the Commission false or misleading information; and National Security Act 2023 offenses, among them assisting a foreign intelligence service, sabotage, foreign interference and supporting a designated body, plus electoral offenses meeting that act's foreign power or designated body condition. Two repealed offenses under the Official Secrets Acts of 1911 and 1920 cover conduct from before the 2023 act came into force. The consultation says aggravated offenses based on disability, sexual orientation and transgender identity will count too once the Crime and Policing Act 2026 extends them, with no change to the regulations.

The government says it has the Law Officer's consent for the new offenses to count even when the offense was committed before the rules take effect, as long as the conviction is not spent. People caught by the automatic rules would have six months from the start date before their disqualification bites, and could apply for a waiver in that time.

For discretionary disqualification, there would be two new conditions. One covers people who have been deprived of British citizenship or excluded from the U.K. The other covers anyone who holds or has held a charity post and has engaged in conduct, or expressed views, that promote or encourage violence or racial or religious hatred, or would be reasonably likely to. The consultation says the behavior need not reach a criminal threshold and need not be linked to the person's charity role, so posts on a personal social media account could count. One of its examples is a trustee calling for violence against a national, ethnic, racial or religious group in a sermon on charity premises.

So far, the consultation says, the Commission has had to rely on a broader condition, conduct likely to damage public trust in charities, and argue each extremism case, which can bring challenge and delay. The consultation puts the average cost to the Commission of a discretionary disqualification at about £7,000, while an automatic one requires no action from the regulator.

How often the Commission disqualifies people

The Commission has made more than 200 disqualification orders since the power was introduced in 2016, according to the consultation, which gives yearly counts for the eight financial years to March 2026.

Disqualification orders made by the Charity Commission for England and Wales, by financial year ending March 31 (source: DCMS consultation, October 2026)
Financial year endingOrders made
March 201922
March 202032
March 202116
March 202212
March 202311
March 202434
March 202537
March 202625

Sixteen appeals against orders have gone to a hearing before the Tribunal. It upheld all but two, though it shortened the ban in two cases and carved out senior management roles in another; the two others were quashed. The consultation does not estimate how many more people the new rules would catch.

Free speech and the sector's concerns

The consultation asks for views on how the powers can guard charities without limiting free expression, legitimate debate or campaigning. It says the new condition is not meant to capture “mere offence or unpleasantness” or to stop legitimate debates or speakers, and that the Commission would still have to show that a person is unfit and that disqualifying them is in the public interest.

Civil Society Minister Vicky Foxcroft said that “where people seek to use charities as a platform to promote hatred or violence, we need to make sure the Charity Commission has the powers it needs to act.” David Holdsworth, CEO of the Charity Commission, said that “Lawful freedom of speech is fundamental to any democracy” but that “there is no place in the charity sector for the promotion of violence or racial or religious hatred.”

In April, the Charity Finance Group said it had joined 17 other civil society organizations in a letter to Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy asking for the sector to be consulted before any expansion of the Commission's powers. CFG's co-CEO, Clare Mills, said the group wanted to understand how extremism would be defined, adding: “We want to ensure any changes don’t have the unintended consequence of curbs on legitimate campaigning by charities and other organisations that exist to drive positive change.” CFG says DCMS and the Commission have responded to the letter, which predates the consultation.

What happens next

The government says it aims to publish a summary of responses and its own response, with an implementation plan, within 12 weeks of the close, and to bring forward the regulations “when Parliamentary time allows.” Wider measures from its March action plan on social cohesion, Protecting What Matters, such as wider powers to suspend trustees and shut down charities, would need new primary legislation and are outside this consultation.

Sources

  1. Consultation on the extension of the Charity Commission’s powers to tackle extremism (consultation page) Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (GOV.UK), October 14, 2026
  2. Consultation on the extension of the Charity Commission’s powers to tackle extremism (consultation document) Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (GOV.UK), October 14, 2026
  3. Planned Draft Charities Act 2011 (Amendment) (Trustee Disqualification) Regulations 2026: for consultation Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (GOV.UK), October 14, 2026
  4. Consultation on powers to protect charities from extremist abuse Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport and Vicky Foxcroft MP (GOV.UK), October 14, 2026
  5. CFG signs joint letter regarding new Charity Commission powers Charity Finance Group, April 15, 2026

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 5 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 16, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.