Policy & LawExplainer
The 2025 Catholic Charities ruling against a proselytizing test for a charity's unemployment tax exemption
In 2025 the Supreme Court held Wisconsin's top court violated the First Amendment by tying a religious exemption to proselytizing or serving only Catholics.
By Policy Desk · Published
In brief
- On June 5, 2025, a unanimous Supreme Court held that Wisconsin's top court violated the First Amendment in applying the state's religious exemption from unemployment tax to Catholic Charities Bureau and four affiliates.
- Wisconsin's top court had ruled the charities were not "operated primarily for religious purposes" because they neither proselytized nor limited their services to Catholics.
- The Court said that test favored some religions over others based on their doctrine, and that Wisconsin failed to justify it under strict scrutiny.
- More than 40 states have adopted exemptions similar to one in federal unemployment tax law, the opinion notes; Wisconsin's tracks the federal wording.
- The case went back to Wisconsin's courts; the Supreme Court's docket shows the record returned on August 5, 2025.
On June 5, 2025, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled unanimously in Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission (No. 24-154) that the Wisconsin Supreme Court's application of the state's religious exemption from unemployment tax to a group of church-controlled charities violated the First Amendment. The state court had denied them the exemption because they did not proselytize or serve only fellow Catholics. Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote for the Court, which reversed the Supreme Court of Wisconsin and sent the case back for further proceedings.
The exemption at issue
Wisconsin requires most employers to pay into its unemployment fund through payroll taxes; nonprofits can choose instead to reimburse the state for benefits paid to their laid-off workers. Churches are exempt without further conditions. Nonprofits that are "operated, supervised, controlled, or principally supported by a church" are exempt too, but only if they are also "operated primarily for religious purposes," under section 108.02(15)(h)(2) of the Wisconsin Statutes.
The wording is not unique to Wisconsin. The Federal Unemployment Tax Act contains a parallel exemption, and since Congress enacted it in 1970 more than 40 states have adopted similar ones, according to the opinion. Ohio and 18 other states (our count of the opinion's list of friend-of-the-court briefs) filed a brief urging the Court to rule for the charities, as did the Wisconsin State Legislature and many religious groups; the Service Employees International Union, the Freedom From Religion Foundation and others filed briefs on Wisconsin's side.
The charities and their path through Wisconsin's courts
Catholic Charities Bureau carries out the social ministry of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Superior, in Wisconsin. It brought the case with four separately incorporated entities it oversees, including Barron County Development Services, which helps people with disabilities find work, and Black River Industries, which provides daily living services. The diocese controls all of them. Their staff and the people they serve need not be Catholic, and they do not try to inculcate the faith in participants; the charities told the Court that Catholic teaching forbids using works of charity for proselytism.
The charities first asked Wisconsin's Department of Workforce Development for the exemption in 2016 and were refused. An administrative law judge ruled for them, the Labor and Industry Review Commission reinstated the denials, a state trial court sided with the charities and the state Court of Appeals reversed again. On March 14, 2024, the Wisconsin Supreme Court affirmed the denial. It accepted that the church controlled the charities and that their work was religiously motivated, but held that their activities were "secular in nature" because they did not imbue participants with the faith, supply religious materials or limit their services to Catholics.
What the Court decided
The First Amendment requires government neutrality between religions, the Court said, and any denominational preference set by a state faces strict scrutiny. Under the Wisconsin court's reading, the charities could have qualified while doing exactly the same work if they had proselytized or served only Catholics. Eligibility therefore turned on "inherently religious choices," the opinion says, and an exemption with those requirements "establishes a preference for certain religions based on the commands of their religious doctrine."
Wisconsin argued that a religious accommodation should face strict scrutiny only if its lines reflect invidious discrimination, and that the charities were excluded for lacking distinctively religious activity such as worship or religious education. The Court rejected both. Unlike the conscientious-objector exemption at issue in a 1971 case, which was open equally to members of all religions, Wisconsin's test treats religions differently on its face, the opinion says; and decisions about whether to express and inculcate doctrine while doing charitable work are themselves theological choices.
The state also failed strict scrutiny. On its interest in unemployment coverage, the Court noted that the charities run their own unemployment compensation system, with benefits largely equivalent to the state's, and that Wisconsin exempts more than 40 forms of employment, including the same charitable work when a church does it directly. On its interest in keeping out of religious employment disputes, the exemption works at the level of the whole organization, "covering both the janitor and the priest in equal measure." The Court decided only the denominational neutrality claim and did not reach two other constitutional arguments.
| Date | Step |
|---|---|
| 2016 | The charities ask Wisconsin's Department of Workforce Development for the exemption and are refused |
| March 14, 2024 | Supreme Court of Wisconsin rules against the charities |
| December 13, 2024 | U.S. Supreme Court grants review; on December 16 it limits review to the first question presented |
| March 31, 2025 | Argument; the federal government argues as a friend of the court for reversal |
| June 5, 2025 | Judgment reversed and case remanded by a unanimous Court |
| July 7, 2025 | Judgment and mandate issued |
| August 5, 2025 | Record returned to the Supreme Court of Wisconsin |
Two concurring opinions
Justice Clarence Thomas joined the opinion in full but wrote that the Wisconsin court also erred in treating the charities as separate from the diocese, because the First Amendment's church autonomy principles let religious bodies define their own structure. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, also joining in full, read the federal exemption as turning on what an organization does, not why it does it. "It is perfectly consistent with the opinion the Court hands down today for States to align their § 3309(b)(1)(B)-based religious-purposes exemptions with Congress's true focus," she wrote.
What applies now
The judgment is final at the Supreme Court. Its docket, as we read it on November 13, 2026, shows the judgment and mandate issued on July 7, 2025, and the record returned to the Wisconsin Supreme Court on August 5, 2025, with no later entry. A state that applies a church-affiliated charity exemption may not make it depend on whether the charity proselytizes or serves only members of its own faith, by our reading of the holding; Justice Jackson's concurrence points to a test based on the organization's function as one the ruling leaves open.
What has happened on remand in Wisconsin, and whether the charities now hold the exemption, is not shown on the Supreme Court's docket, and we could not confirm it from an official Wisconsin source. Charities with questions about their own status are pointed to their state's unemployment insurance agency.
Sources
- Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission, 605 U.S. 238 (preliminary print) Supreme Court of the United States, June 5, 2025
- Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission, No. 24-154 (slip opinion) Supreme Court of the United States, June 5, 2025
- Docket for 24-154 Supreme Court of the United States, August 5, 2025
Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 3 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 13, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.