News about giving, foundations and nonprofits

AboutStandardsAdvertise

Nonprofits

Charity Commission finds misconduct and/or mismanagement at charity that brought puppy-breeding cases

An inquiry says Animal Protection Services' trustees kept poor records of legal advice and mishandled pay conflicts. It was removed from the register in July.

By Nonprofits Desk ·

In brief

  • The Charity Commission found misconduct and/or mismanagement at Animal Protection Services, which brought private prosecutions of suspected unlicensed puppy breeders, its inquiry report says.
  • Two judges raised concerns about the prosecutions, one calling them an abuse of process; a separate regulator found no misconduct by the charity's law firm.
  • The inquiry found poor records of legal advice and decisions, and paid roles for two founder trustees that were not properly authorized.
  • The charity went into liquidation in 2023 and was removed from the register of charities on July 28, 2026.

The Charity Commission for England and Wales has found misconduct and/or mismanagement at Animal Protection Services, a charity that took people it accused of breeding dogs without a license to court in private prosecutions. The regulator's inquiry report, published on November 12, 2026, says the trustees kept poor records of the legal advice behind those cases and did not properly authorize paid roles for two of the charity's founders.

The charity, registered on November 18, 2019, had objects that included investigating animal cruelty and prosecuting those responsible. It went into liquidation in 2023 and was removed from the register on July 28, 2026. The regulator first opened a case on it in November 2021.

Prosecutions built on puppy ads

In October 2020, the report says, the charity agreed with the law firm Parry and Welch Solicitors LLP (PAWS) to bring private prosecutions of unlicensed dog breeders. The trustees told the inquiry that COVID-19 restrictions had stopped their field work while demand for pets soared. In February 2021, the charity and PAWS signed an information-sharing agreement with an online pet marketplace, which passed on details of people who had placed large numbers of puppy ads. The charity chose whom to investigate from that information and issued summonses for unlicensed breeding. The trustees gave the inquiry evidence that some investigations went further, with identity checks and witness evidence, though the report says concerns remain about a number of cases.

In England, councils license dog breeders. Defra's statutory guidance for council inspectors, updated on June 1, 2026, says a license is needed for breeding three or more litters in any 12-month period, unless the breeder can show that none of the puppies was sold, or for breeding dogs and advertising a business of selling them, and treats a high number of puppy ads as a possible sign of a business.

Concerns from the bench

The charity ended its arrangement with PAWS on September 14, 2021, and on September 22 reported its own concerns about the firm's court work to the Commission. The Commission opened a compliance case that November after complaints and media coverage alleging that the charity and PAWS had brought malicious prosecutions for personal financial gain.

In December 2021, Judge Nicholas Dean QC wrote to the Commission after ruling in one of the cases, describing them as “improper prosecutions brought for improper reasons amounting to abuse of process,” for which he held the charity and PAWS equally responsible. The Commission calls such a referral from a judge very unusual. In January 2022, the Ministry of Justice passed on a Bolton Crown Court judgment by Deputy Circuit Judge HH Tim Clayson, who concluded that the prosecutions “should never have been brought.” The statutory inquiry opened on February 17, 2022.

In January 2024, the Solicitors Regulation Authority identified no misconduct by PAWS and concluded that the prosecutions “were not considered to be unmeritorious,” the report says. The Commission understands that PAWS has since stopped trading. The trustees told the inquiry they had followed PAWS's advice, including that the burden of proof fell on the defendant under section 101 of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980. The inquiry says evidence indicates they did receive such advice, but the charity could not produce enough records of the advice behind several significant decisions.

What the inquiry found

Findings of misconduct and/or mismanagement in the Charity Commission's report, November 12, 2026
IssueWhat the report found
RecordsInadequate records of decisions on cases taken to court and of the legal advice relied on
Trustee oversightOne trustee, in post from February to September 2021, took no meaningful part in running the charity
Jacob Lloyd's paid role, October 2020 to February 2022Permitted by the governing document, but not properly authorized: too few independent trustees in 2020 for the three-trustee decision it required
Serena James's job, May to October 2021Deputy director at £30,000 a year, with no recorded trustee decision and no advertisement
Consultancy, November 2021 to February 2022£21,500.24 paid to Lloyd's company at a discounted £35 an hour; he left the meeting for the decision, but the board may have lacked a quorum

The trustees' minutes from October 2020 cite Lloyd's extensive experience of the charity's work and of animal welfare prosecutions. The report notes, however, that neither he nor James held the investigator qualification the charity had told the Commission its investigators must have.

The end of the charity

In March 2022, the inquiry froze the charity's bank account and ordered Giving.com, which trades as JustGiving, to move the charity's funds into it. In June 2022, the trustees told the regulator that the charity and its trustees had suffered severe reputational damage and that they planned to wind it up; a resolution followed on February 22, 2023. PAWS tried and failed in court to wind up the charity over unpaid fees, and the court awarded the charity £22,000, the report says.

For the wider sector, the Commission says trustees stay responsible for governance even when they rely on professional advice. The report does not say how many prosecutions the charity brought or how many ended in convictions.

Sources

  1. Charity Inquiry: Animal Protection Services The Charity Commission (GOV.UK), November 12, 2026
  2. Charity Inquiry: Animal Protection Services (publication page) The Charity Commission (GOV.UK), November 12, 2026
  3. Dog breeding licensing: statutory guidance for local authorities Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (GOV.UK), June 1, 2026

Researched and drafted with AI assistance, then checked against the 3 sources above in a separate fact-check on November 12, 2026. Spotted an error? Tell us.